
Oil City
(Points scored wearing OCHS uniform)
CAREER SCORING
Boys
1,130 -- Ben Schill, 1996
975 -- Chris Jasiota, 2003
949 -- Logan Way, 2014
842 -- Cam Van Wormer, 2023
831 -- Mike Koziara, 1994
830 -- Jackson McFall, 2016
792 -- Holden Stahl, 2021
788 -- Dallas Williams, 2011
762 -- Matt May, 2009
757 -- Dutch Burch, 1950
745 -- Andrew Williams, 2014
745 -- Morgan Hadley, 2016
735 -- Judias Johnson, 2022
734 -- Jake Hornbeck, 2023
GIRLS
1,346 -- Tracy Whitling, 1997
1,217 -- Jackie Craft, 1997
1,149 -- Jodi Gault, 1975
1,093 -- Riley Davis, 2015
1,044 -- Peggy Gregory, 1989
1,038 -- Sarah McCauley, 2017
1,020 -- Bridget Hale, 1986
1,010 -- Trish Erickson, 1977
963 -- Melinda Hale, 1973
882 -- Joan Smith, 1982
771 -- Jane Hajduk, 1985
750 -- Kevaney Martin, 750**
751 -- Joan Pleger, 1981***
700 -- Karen Smith, 1982*
'Modern era' pre-winter
626 -- Peg McDougal, 1975 (junior and senior seasons only)
SINGLE-SEASON SCORING
Boys
498 -- Mike Emick, 1971
434 -- Ron McCoid, 1966
431 -- Ben Schill, 1996
417 -- Morgan Hadley, 2015
401 -- Logan Way, 2013
Girls
555 -- Bridget Hale, 1986
537 -- Joan Smith, 1982
527 -- Jodi Gault, 1975
481 -- Trish Erickson, 1977
460 -- Peg McDougal, 1975
451 -- Peggy Gregory, 1989
414 -- Jane Hajduk, 1984
36 or more
Boys
56 -- Mike Emick, 1971
51 -- Al Foster, 1918
45 -- Tom Mix, 1970
44 -- Ron McCoid, 1966
Girls
48 -- Trish Erickson, 1976 (fall)
46 -- Bridget Hale (2X), 1986
42 -- Bridget Hale, 1986
39 -- Peggy Gregory, 1989
37 -- Peggy Gregory, 1989
OF NOTE -- Jay Schill finished with 1,573 points, but only 255 of those came at Oil City. Jackson McFall's career total includes 267 he scored as a Christian Life Academy ninth-grader. Joan Smith scored 882 of her 1,205 points for Oil City; the rest came as a freshman and sophomore for Venango Christian.
* -- record incomplete
** -- transfer from VC, where she played as a freshman. Scored 456 points for Oil City before illness cut her playing career short.
*** -- Lynne Licht would be on this list too, but missing 15 games from 1979-81 seasons
Rebounds
Game
Boys
Mike Emick -- 36, 32, 31 (2X), 1971
Girls
Peg McDougal -- 36, 1975
Season
Boys
287 -- Matt May, 2009
274 -- Andy Scierka, 1989
256+ -- Mike Emick, 1971*
249 -- Chris Jasiota, 2003
244 -- Dave Pearson, 1964
233 -- Dallas Williams, 2010
226 -- Dave Hodges, 1974
209 -- Tim Teeter, 1977
* -- Emick had the 256 in 10 of the 25 games The Derrick had individual totals listed
Girls
398 -- Peg McDougal, 1975
354 -- Peggy Gregory, 1988
236 -- Heather Schneeberger, 1991
232 -- Peg McDougal, 1974
217 -- Lynne Licht, 1980
212 -- Peggy Gregory, 1987
Career
Boys
700+ -- Ben Schill, 1996**
532 -- Chris Jasiota, 2003
** -- Schill received a plaque from coach Dan Fry late in the season for his 700 career points and rebounds
Girls
1,213 -- Tracy Whitling, 1996
630 -- Peg McDougal, 1975
566 -- Peggy Gregory as soph and junior
3-pointers
Game
Boys
9 -- Tyler Lukasiak, 2017
Season
Boys
65 -- P.J. McGinty, 2004
51 -- P.J. McGinty, 2005
Girls
39 -- Amanda Jones, 2005
37 -- Amanda Jones, 2003
35 -- Janelle Hall, 1997
33 -- Maddy Neely, 2019
32 -- Chelsea Hall, 2012
32 -- Kerri Wilkinson, 2003
31 -- Jen Stevenson, 2016
Career
Boys
128 -- P.J. McGinty, 2005
112 -- Cam Van Wormer, 2023
107 -- Nolan Carll, 2009
92 -- Brendan Brown, 1991
90 -- Tyler Lukasiak, 2016
76 -- Dallas Williams, 2011
Girls
102 -- Amanda Jones, 2005*
85 -- Janelle Hall, 1997
83 -- Chelsea Hall, 2012
82 -- Jen Stevenson, 2016
62 -- Mya Hidinger, 2011
* -- record incomplete
Assists
Boys
Season
120 -- Jake Hornbeck, 2023
94 -- Dutch Burch, 1950
Girls
Season
183 -- Janelle Hall, 1996
169 -- Erin Morris, 1993
Career
361 -- Janelle Hall, 1997
Steals
Girls
Season
107 -- Erin Morris, 1993
Free throw shooting
Jon Settlemire -- 13/13 in a 1971 game
Ron McCoid -- 85% in 1965; 39/41 including stretches of 14/14 and 10/10, 1965
C.J. Fletcher, 83% (64-77), 2003
Cam Van Wormer -- 30/33 including 21/21 stretch, 2023
Mike Emick -- 16/17 during 56-point game, 1971
P.J. McGinty was an 80% (49/61) shooter from the line in 2006
Legend
Rick Fletcher -- 25 rebounds and five blocks of layups in first quarter alone in playoff game against Meadville, 1970
Odds and Ends
Jodi Gault -- 44 assists in six playoff games in 1975

From the Oil Can: Your 1948 Oilers. Dutch Burch is No. 27 in the back and Dick Erickson is No. 30.

Other Numbers of Note
Mike Emick sat out the last 5:30 in the game (121-48 Oiler victory) he scored 56 against Rocky Grove on Feb. 9, 1971. He tied the Section 2 record set on Jan. 19, 1954, by Meadville's Lloyd Sharrar against Franklin...Emick had 22 points and 32 rebounds against the Grove earlier in the 1971-72 season...Emick had five games of 30 or more rebounds, including a high of 36 against Franklin. He totaled 256 boards in the 10 (of 25) games that rebounds were reported to the newspaper...Injuries his junior year might have cost him membership in the 700 club; he totaled 600 points in his two seasons on the varsity...
Emick bucketed 20 field goals and was 16/17 from the line; Al Foster had 22 field goals and was 7/16 from the line when he scored 51 against Titusville, a 105-14 victory, in 1918...All of Oil City's 40-point plus game came in February...
The Oilers' highest scoring quarter when Emick bucketed 56 against the Grove was 41 in the third -- not the school record. The Oilers scored 43 points in a game against Corry during the 1955-56 season.
Anecdote about Bridget Hale's 46-point game. Coach Peg McDougal took her out with three minutes left and afterward contacted former OCHS coach Rick Fletcher only to be told the school record was Trish Erickson's 48...Erickson, by the way, was featured in "Faces in the Crowd" in Sports illustrated...
Ron McCoid made 22 straight free throws in five Section 2 games during the 1964-65 season. Counting all games from Jan. 8-Feb. 2, McCoid was 39-for-41 from the line. He was 14/14 vs. Franklin, East and Warren, then went 9/10 vs. Vincent, but it's not known when he missed. He followed that up by going 10/10 vs. Titusville and Corry before missing once in seven tries vs. Franklin. He shot 85% (57/67) for the season...Cam Van Wormer was a free throw made short of matching McCoid. He made 21 straight, his streak starting Feb. 3 vs. Titusville and ending when he missed the second of a two-shot foul March 11 against Neshannock. Van Wormer shot 76.2% during the 2022-23 campaign, including 30 of 33 during a 16-game stretch...Here's another one: Jon Settlemire was 13/13 at the line in a 1971 game...
Tyler Lukasiak canned a school record nine three-pointers in a 2016 game ...Brendan Brown made 92 three-pointers in his two years as a starter in 1990-91...C.J. Fletcher is one behind with 91 trifectas as a two-year regular in 2003-04; he scored 637 points during that time. This includes a 32-point, five-trey effort in February 2003...Don't know if he played as a soph...I count 112 three-pointers for Cam VanWormer, but have no idea what the school record is...Devon Geib (2014) just missed "the list"; he had 699 career points...Jackson McFall scored 830 of his 1,097 career points at Oil City, the rest as a CLA ninth-grader...
Tracy Whitling, 6-4, not only holds the career scoring record among girls with 1,346 points, but she has the rebounding record, too, with 1,213...
Peg McDougal pulled down 36 rebounds in a game and 398 for the 1974-75 campaign...Janelle Hall finished her career with 361 assists and 85 3-pointers...Erin Morris made 107 steals during the 1992-93 campaign...She handed out 169 assists and was credited with the school record; Hall had 150 assists as her senior season began winding down...Speaking of assists: Stats for Jodi Gault were not kept all the time; however, she dished out 44 assists in Oil City's six playoff games in 1975. The Oilerettes were 22-1, and she had 72 in the 14 that that stat was kept...Getting back to McDougal: with Gault hobbled by an elbow injury, but still clutch; McDougal averaged 24.7 points and 19 rebounds in the six post-season games in which Oil City reached the state semifinal before losing to Elizabeth-Forward...
Hud Wells said Dick Erickson's 216-point season in 1948 was the most points anyone at Oil City had ever scored since he started coaching the Oilers in 1931...The Oilers had two 30-point scorers on Feb. 4, 1956, when Bob Hartz netted 35 and Howdy Rose 32 in a 102-57 romp over Corry...
Six-foot-seven Chris Jasiota averaged a double-double 16.7 points and 10.8 rebounds for the 2003 Oilers before heading off to Juniata, where he scored 959 points as a four-year regular. Jasiota was a three-time all-conference choice, making the first team (TCAC as it was known then) as a junior and senior...Mike Koziara, 6-6, was given a ball from coach Dan Fry before a late-season game in 1994 commemorating his 700 points and 700 rebounds...
The Oilers, then coached by Jason Fulmer, ended Farrell's 50-game winning streak against District 10 competition with a 53-49 decision on Jan. 20, 2010. It was also the Steelers' first-ever region loss. Dallas Williams scored 22 points and pulled down 16 rebounds in that game...Speaking of streaks, the Oil City girls had their 43-game Section 2 skein stopped at Corry, 63-37, on Sept. 16,1975. Oil City had never lost a league game until the game...The Oilerettes also had a 26-game overall winning streak snapped by Bradford, 49-46, on Set. 30, 1972...
From the Never Say Never Dept.: On March 1, 1948, The News Herald reported: "Dick Erickson set a modern scoring record at Oil City with 216 points...His record might be for ALL-TIME (caps mine) (since) available scoring fugues show him to be the only Oil City basketball in recent years to exceed the two century mark"...Now I realize the Oilers have had only ONE player to score 1,000 career points wearing an OCHS uniform (Ben Schill) and no male player has ever scored more than 500 points in a season (Mike Emick's 498 in 1971 is the school record), but come on. I would not, here in 2023, say that 498 is going to stand for all-time. I'm old enough to know you NEVER say never...P.S. This is a school that had already produced a single-game 51-point outburst. In 1918, yet!


Oil City did field a girls basketball team in 1925. Fifty years later the "Oilerettes," led by Jodi Gault and Peg McDougal, reached the state semifinals where they lost to Elizabeth-Forward to finish with a 22-1 record under coach Dixie Cox -- later Agnew. Oil City dominated in the early years of "modern" girls basketball, capturing seven of the first league titles with Rick Fletcher following Agnew as coach.

Evolution of Scoring Records

Found this while googling for images of Rich Ahrens, the Oilers' 7-footer of the mid-1930s.
Ahrens had a tryout with the old Washington Senators. He didn't make it, but, as you can see, he towered over everybody. Here, he is with 5-8 Milton Haefner and 5-7 Bobby Estelalla.
According to a piece titled "The Biggest Nat" by Karen and Kevin Flynn in D.C. Baseball History, Ahrens was discovered by scout Joe Cambria when he walked into a grocery store and found Ahrens stocking shelves.
"He was behind the counter reaching for some cans on the top shelf. And when I saw him I thought he was standing on a ladder. But I did not see any ladder so I signed him.”
Ahrens, a pitcher, reported to spring training in 1943. His feet were too big for regulation baseball shoes.
Although he never made it to "the show," he was listed on the roster for the 1943 Utica club in the Eastern League and later on the 1945 Elizabethton Betsy Cubs of the Appalachian League. No statistics are listed for him.
Was it just a publicity stunt? asked the Flynns. We will never know.